在计算机视觉领域,CVPR(IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition)是最重要的学术会议之一。对于研究人员而言,成功投稿并获得审稿意见后,撰写一份有效的Rebuttal(反驳信)是提升论文被接受几率的关键环节。本文将提供一份结构清晰、逻辑严谨的CVPR Rebuttal写作模板,帮助作者更好地回应审稿人的意见。
一、开头部分
首先,在Rebuttal的开头应简要说明自己对审稿人意见的重视,并表达感谢。这部分不需要太长,但需要体现出专业性和礼貌性。
例如:
> We would like to thank the reviewers for their thoughtful comments and suggestions. We have carefully read and considered all the feedback, and we believe that our revised manuscript addresses the concerns raised.
二、逐条回应审稿意见
这是Rebuttal的核心部分,需针对每一条审稿意见进行逐一回应。建议采用以下结构:
1. 明确指出审稿意见编号(如:“Regarding Comment 1”)
2. 简要重述审稿意见(避免直接复制,用自己语言表达)
3. 解释或证明自己的观点(可以引用文献、实验数据、图表等)
4. 说明修改内容(如果已进行修改)
示例:
> Regarding Comment 1: The reviewer pointed out that the comparison with existing methods is not comprehensive. We agree with this concern and have added a new section (Section 3.2) that compares our method with three additional state-of-the-art approaches. The results are presented in Table 2, which demonstrates the superiority of our approach in terms of both accuracy and efficiency.
三、处理质疑与争议
有时审稿人可能会提出一些具有争议性的观点,比如对方法合理性的质疑。在这种情况下,应以理性、客观的态度进行回应,必要时可引用相关研究或提供额外的实验支持。
例如:
> Regarding Comment 5: The reviewer questions the feasibility of using multi-scale features in our framework. We would like to clarify that we have conducted additional experiments on different scale combinations, and the results show that the multi-scale feature fusion significantly improves performance. We have included these results in the revised version (Section 4.3).
四、总结与感谢
最后,应在Rebuttal结尾部分对审稿人再次表示感谢,并表明愿意继续改进论文的意愿。
例如:
> Once again, we sincerely appreciate the time and effort the reviewers have invested in evaluating our work. We hope that the revised manuscript has adequately addressed all the concerns and look forward to the opportunity to contribute to CVPR.
五、注意事项
- 避免使用过于情绪化的语言,保持专业和冷静。
- 不要对审稿人进行攻击或反驳,即使有不同意见也应礼貌表达。
- 确保所有修改内容在文中已有体现,避免“纸上谈兵”。
- 如果某些问题无法完全解决,应诚恳说明原因,并提出未来工作的方向。
六、结语
撰写一份高质量的CVPR Rebuttal不仅是对审稿意见的回应,更是展示研究者学术态度和专业素养的重要机会。通过结构化、逻辑清晰的写作方式,能够有效提升论文被接受的可能性。希望本模板能为您的Rebuttal写作提供有价值的参考。